The stock market never stops surprising people. It constantly shifts, adapts, and breaks every narrative investors think they have figured out. Just when it seems like the formula makes sense, the market rewrites its own rules.
That reality has played out again this year. Many investors expected U.S. automakers to be crushed by the trade war and new tariffs. Instead, Ford and General Motors have become two of the most unexpected success stories of 2025.
How Ford and GM Defied Expectations
At the start of the year, few analysts predicted that Detroit’s automakers would outperform tech stocks. The consensus view was that tariffs, inflation, and slowing global demand would slam their margins.
But the market had other plans. Instead of being weighed down by tariffs, Ford and GM are benefiting from the wealth effect. Rising portfolio values are keeping higher-income consumers confident enough to spend big on cars and trucks, even as prices remain elevated.
Ford stock has gained roughly 41% year-to-date, its best return since 2021. GM is up about 32%, building on a 50% surge last year. If the year ended today, both companies would outperform Tesla, something that has only happened three times since Tesla’s IPO in 2010.
GM’s Breakout Year
General Motors reported a strong quarter earlier this month, beating both revenue and earnings estimates while raising its full-year guidance. That announcement sparked a 15% jump in its share price, marking GM’s second-best trading day since 2009.
The company expected between $4 billion and $5 billion in tariff-related costs this year, but believes it can offset roughly 35% of those expenses through efficiency gains and higher pricing power. GM also achieved its highest U.S. market share since 2017 at 17%, with 710,000 vehicle deliveries.
EV sales were another bright spot. GM delivered 67,000 electric vehicles, securing a 16.5% share of the U.S. EV market. The company expects profitability in its electric segment to improve further in 2026 as warranty costs fall and tariff exposure declines.
GM has also been aggressive in returning capital to shareholders through buybacks and has become more profitable than Ford in recent years, which explains its stronger stock performance.
Ford’s Comeback Story
A few days after GM’s strong report, Ford posted its own impressive results. The company beat top- and bottom-line expectations and reported record revenue up 9% year over year. The iconic F-Series remains on track to be America’s best-selling truck for the 49th straight year.
Analysts project that Ford will deliver 32% earnings-per-share growth next year, placing it among the top five S&P 500 consumer discretionary companies by earnings momentum. Despite this, the stock still trades at just nine times forward earnings, which could attract value investors looking for relative bargains.
Why These Stocks Are Rising Now
The biggest tailwind is confidence. The Federal Reserve’s decision to lower rates below 4% has reduced borrowing costs, and that will soon flow through to auto loans.
Cox Automotive expects that lower interest rates in early 2026 combined with record-high tax refunds will drive a fresh wave of car buying. That dynamic could extend the rally for both Ford and GM into next year.
It is also worth noting that both companies have become more disciplined. They are managing supply chains more effectively, cutting unnecessary costs, and maintaining strong pricing power even as competitors discount inventory.
What Investors Should Watch
Despite the recent strength, investors should stay disciplined. Both stocks have history on their side but also carry unique risks.
For Ford, the turnaround is still fragile. The company has been slower to adapt than GM, focusing heavily on dividends rather than buybacks. Its chart shows strong resistance around $14 per share and potential support near $12, which aligns with its 50-day moving average. A sustained move above $14 would confirm continued momentum, while a drop below $12 could signal renewed weakness.
For GM, the setup looks more advanced. With a market cap around $65 billion and a mid-single-digit forward price-to-earnings ratio, it remains cheap by most metrics. The recent surge through $60 per share broke a resistance level that has held since late 2024. Still, a short-term pullback toward the $62 area would not be surprising. That range should be watched as a key support level.
The Bigger Picture
The success of Ford and GM offers a larger lesson for investors. Markets often defy expectations because they move based on what is next, not what is now. Tariffs were supposed to crush margins and demand. Instead, companies adapted faster than predicted, passing on costs, streamlining production, and benefiting from a confident consumer base.
If rate cuts continue and the U.S. avoids a major slowdown, both automakers could remain strong performers into 2026. But if the macro picture shifts — for instance, if the trade war reignites or consumers pull back spending — these stocks could quickly give up their gains.
Key Takeaways for Investors
- Tariffs are not always destiny. U.S. automakers are proving that adaptability and cost control can offset policy headwinds.
- Valuations still look reasonable. GM and Ford trade at significant discounts to the broader market, leaving room for multiple expansion if earnings growth continues.
- The wealth effect is real. Rising portfolios are keeping consumers spending even in a high-cost environment.
- Risk management matters. Investors should monitor key technical levels and use stop-loss orders to protect gains.
Both Ford and GM are old-economy names that have learned new tricks. Their recent performance reminds investors that even in a volatile market, the most unexpected winners can come from industries everyone had written off.
About Author
