Trump Fires His Cyber Chief. If the Outages Weren’t Attacks, Why?

Trump and the Silent Monitor

The Trump administration says the outages that grounded flights, disrupted banking and knocked out business communications were separate technical failures. A day after the White House publicly dismissed the idea of a coordinated cyberattack, Trump backed the firing of his national cyber director, Sean Cairncross. The timing raises an obvious question: If hackers didn’t cause the outages, why replace the person in charge of U.S. cyber strategy?

The disruptions were already having consequences outside Washington. As we reported Wednesday, outage fears were sending some shoppers to Costco for emergency supplies. Mizuho linked some of the retailer’s stronger sales to that anxiety. The shopping surge showed how quickly people can lose confidence in systems they rely on, even when officials say the problems are unrelated.

The Push to Replace Cairncross Started Before the Outages

White House Chief of Staff Stephen Miller had long wanted Cairncross out, according to CBS News. Miller reportedly questioned whether Cairncross had the cybersecurity expertise the job required. Axios separately reported that Miller pushed for the change, and Reuters cited a source close to the White House who said Trump fully supported the firing.

The White House is turning to Kirsten Davies, the Pentagon’s chief information officer, to take over on an interim basis. Davies has held senior cybersecurity roles in government and the private sector, including overseeing cyber resilience at Unilever. Her appointment fits the reported push for someone with more direct experience managing security and technology systems. It remains unclear whether the outages accelerated a decision Miller was already pressing for.

The national cyber director advises the president and coordinates federal cybersecurity policy. The office doesn’t operate an airline’s systems or approve a bank’s software updates. Its remit does include how the government manages technology risk and coordinates across agencies, which puts it in the spotlight when several important services go down in quick succession.

This week illustrated a problem that can arise even when companies are trying to make their systems safer. Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton said some disruptions occurred when systems were patched or upgraded and failed to come back as expected. A security fix can reduce the risk of a future breach while creating an immediate problem if an essential service can’t recover from a bad update. How quickly that service comes back matters to anyone trying to catch a flight, access a bank account or run a business.

There was a confirmed cyberattack involving JPMorgan Chase’s outside vendors. The Associated Press reported Thursday that attackers accessed information including customer email addresses and some phone numbers. Chase said that breach was separate from its earlier banking outage, which it attributed to a software bug. Public reporting has established no link between the vendor breach and Cairncross’s firing.

The Next Test Is Whether Washington Funds the Fixes

Air traffic control offers a concrete example. After the nationwide ground stop, the administration called for full funding to modernize the system. For investors following government technology contractors, the developments that matter are whether Congress provides funding and whether agencies turn it into contracts. A change at the top of the cyber office doesn’t tell you who will get that work or when.

The same distinction applies to banks, airlines and other companies that depend on systems running around the clock. An outage can lead to lost transactions, customer compensation or extra spending on backup systems. In the next round of earnings calls, listen for two specifics: whether management can put a dollar figure on the disruption, and whether the company needs to spend more to prevent a repeat.

Miller’s reported concerns about Cairncross’s experience offer the clearest explanation for the firing. What remains unanswered is why the White House acted when it did. Davies’s first test will be whether the administration can explain what failed, who is responsible for fixing it and how Americans will know those fixes worked.

About Author

Leave a Reply